Earring Mystery Box

Rated 4.89 out of 5 46 reviews

$ 37.00 $ 49.00

( / )
Unavailable

Please select all options.

Notify me when this item is back in stock:

Details

✨ Sustainably Handmade in the USA

✨SAMPLE SALE! MYSTERY BOXES! OH MY!✨

Each mystery box contains three pairs of earrings thoughtfully curated just for you! The earrings included will be a collection of retired styles or earrings that are a bit too unique to fit the descriptions on our regular listings. For these mystery boxes we will be including a variation of the following styles:

-Yellow gold stud earrings

-Rose gold stud earrings

-Silver stud earrings

-Yellow gold edgy earrings

✨We are no longer able to accommodate requests on these boxes, as we have limited quantities available. ✨

Some of these earrings contain small flaws that make them too unique to be sold on our full price listings, but these flaws do not detract from the quality or wearability of the piece. While these earrings may be a little different, they still need a good home and deserve to be shown off :)

Gold earrings:

-Pure 14k gold fill Post and Back

-24k Gold Dipped

-Copper around the stone to form the setting

Silver earrings:

-Sterling silver post and back

-Copper around the stone to form the setting

-Sterling silver plating

Rose Gold earrings:

-Sterling silver post and back

-Copper around the stone to form the setting

-18k Rose Gold Dipped Setting

Materials
What it is made of
  • Ring shanks are 14k gold-filled, plated with 24k gold for a deeper color.
  • 925 Sterling Silver is offered on pieces that list a silver option.
  • We work in recycled precious metals wherever we can, so each piece asks a little less of the earth.
  • Gemstones are genuine raw stones, so color and shape are unique to every piece.

100% hand crafted in our Atlanta Studio.

Shipping & Returns
Shipping
  • Shipping within the US is free on every order. In-stock pieces arrive by USPS in 2 to 5 business days.
  • Made-to-order pieces are handcrafted within 10-15 business days, then ship by the same free USPS service. Mixed orders ship together once the made-to-order piece is finished.
  • We ship worldwide. International rates are calculated by USPS at checkout; European orders include a $3.50 handling fee.
  • Customs duties, import taxes, and brokerage fees are the buyer's responsibility and are collected by your local authorities.
  • Every order ships with tracking.
Returns
  • Return an unworn piece within 100 days from the day your order is delivered, in its original packaging with all tags and pouches included.
  • Custom, made-to-order, personalized, engraved, and special-order pieces cannot be returned or exchanged unless they arrive damaged or differ from what was ordered. Gift cards and final-sale items are non-returnable.
  • Return shipping is the customer's responsibility. If the error is ours, we cover it and send a prepaid label.
  • Email support@ringcrush.com with your order number to start a return; refunds are issued to the original payment method within 3 to 5 business days of arrival.

Full details: Shipping Policy · Refund Policy

Questions
Are the gemstones real? Will mine look like the photo?

Every stone we set is a genuine gemstone, left raw and cut by nature rather than by a machine. That is the whole point of the piece, and it is also why no two are alike: color, shape, and the inclusions inside the stone shift from one to the next, and the same stone reads differently depending on the light and the angle you catch it at. Your piece will be a close cousin of the one photographed, never an identical twin.

Does it come with a gift box?

Yes. Every order arrives in our gift box, ready to give as it is. No extra charge and nothing to ask for at checkout.

A Ringcrush piece in its gift box
What does gold fill actually mean?

Gold fill is not plating. A thick layer of solid gold is bonded to a brass core under heat and pressure, and by law it has to be at least 1/20 of the item's weight, which is why you see it written as 14k gold-filled (1/20). That layer is many times thicker than gold plate, so it does not rub off the way plated jewelry does and it holds up to daily wear for years.

For reference, from most to least gold: solid gold, then gold fill, then heavy plate, then flash plate. Most high-street jewelry is flash plate, which is a microscopically thin coat that wears through in months. We use gold fill, with a 24k dip over it for a deeper color.

How do I care for it?

Very little upkeep. Keep it away from chlorine, harsh cleansers, and household chemicals, and take it off before swimming. An occasional buff with a soft dry cloth is usually all it asks for, and it is happiest stored somewhere dry and out of direct sun. Cared for that way, gold-filled and sterling pieces are made to be worn every day.

Still unsure about something? Email support@ringcrush.com and we will help.

✨ Free U.S. Shipping

✨ Sustainably Handmade in the USA

✨PLEASE READ FULL DESCRIPTION! These mystery boxes are FINAL SALE - no returns, exchanges, or resizes✨

✨SAMPLE SALE! MYSTERY BOXES! OH MY!✨

Each mystery box contains three pairs of earrings thoughtfully curated just for you! The earrings included will be a collection of retired styles or earrings that are a bit too unique to fit the descriptions on our regular listings. For these mystery boxes we will be including a variation of the following styles:

-Yellow gold stud earrings
-Rose gold stud earrings
-Silver stud earrings
-Yellow gold edgy earrings

✨We are no longer able to accommodate requests on these boxes, as we have limited quantities available. ✨

Some of these earrings contain small flaws that make them too unique to be sold on our full price listings, but these flaws do not detract from the quality or wearability of the piece. While these earrings may be a little different, they still need a good home and deserve to be shown off :)

Gold earrings:
-Pure 14k gold fill Post and Back
-24k Gold Dipped
-Copper around the stone to form the setting

Silver earrings:
-Sterling silver post and back
-Copper around the stone to form the setting
-Sterling silver plating

Rose Gold earrings:
-Sterling silver post and back
-Copper around the stone to form the setting
-18k Rose Gold Dipped Setting

Complete the look

Reviews

4.89 46 reviews
  • 5★ 42
  • 4★ 3
  • 3★ 1
  • 2★ 0
  • 1★ 0

Some reviews were originally left by buyers on our Etsy shop and imported here, with their original dates and ratings kept exactly as written.

  1. LM

    This is the second set of mystery earrings I have purchased. I am planning on ordering a third set! They are beautiful!!

  2. dentsdelion

    I've had great experiences with the ring mystery boxes, so I was excited to try the earring mystery box. I am SO thrilled with my earrings! I had requested gold metal if possible (knowing that it was just a request, and might not happen), and I got three beautiful pairs of gold studs! The stones are gorgeous and I am so excited to wear them all!

  3. Michele

    Your TEAM is the BEST! I love each pair of earrings you sent to me in the Mystery Box. I immediately put on the large raw turquoise earrings to enjoy as I volunteer at the hospital with Becky. :) Thank you for the great quality!

  4. Faith

    Beautiful in person the colors are ethereal

  5. Faith

    Beautiful earrings great value well made

  6. LM

    I received absolutely beautiful earrings! I want to order another mystery box!

  7. jstancil

    I liked the earrings I received!

  8. Rebecca

    Fun selection. I like the surprise factor.

  9. Heather

    Ringcrush’s mystery boxes are so fun and always a rewarding surprise!

  10. Akane

    I’m so happy with them! Thanks ringcrush🫶

  11. Verified Etsy buyer

    This mystery 3 sets of earrings were a perfect gift for my daughter. She has been wearing a different pair each day since she received them and loves them! They are beautifully crafted.

  12. Jessica

    I asked for green and yellow and she was not in the obligation to do it. Still, she did it and I got exactly what I asked for despite the fact that I bought a mystery box 🙏🏻🥹🫠 wow, thank you so much 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻

  13. Ash

    The items itself is beautiful! Hoping to buy more from this store :)

  14. Katelyn

    Love everything as always! Thanks

  15. Sign in with Apple user

    Love these all so much! This is good quality as my ears can tell if they are not! :)

  16. Carisa

    These earrings were so cute. I only plan to wear the emerald ones but those alone are worth the price!

  17. The bored fridge

    Amazing as always,I love every piece I get.

  18. Elizabeth

    Gorgeous! Was so pleasantly surprised and loved the variety (tiny diamonds with gold backings, large emerald gold loops, and small turquoise set in rose gold). Will probably try the mystery ring package next time!

  19. Sign in with Apple user

    Beautiful pieces, cute and unique

  20. Hayley

    Love all 3 of them!

  21. Megan

    I have purchased two ring mystery boxes in the past and loved everything in them. Was excited to purchase the earring mystery box. I gave four stars because one of the earrings has a few small chunks out of the gem. I understand that mystery boxes are often leftover stock and the chunks won't be overly noticeable when worn, just was a little disappointed.

  22. Megan

    Very cute necklace. Looking forward to pairing it with past earrings and rings I had also purchased from ringcrush.

  23. Jessica

    My earrings are beautiful and so original!! This is my second mystery box and I would buy again!

  24. Lauren

    Got this for my sister, she loves it!

  25. Lauren

    Came quick, love it sm!

  26. Joseph

    As described, fast turnaround and high quality!

  27. Lydia

    This should be a subscription! I loved the selection and various sizes. Totally would order again!

  28. ldadams65

    Loved one pair, didn’t like the other two. Would’ve been nice to know what kind of stones they were. That was my risk in choosing the mystery box, though. Love everything else I’ve purchased from this shop.

  29. Julie Evans

    Beautiful earrings & nice mix of styles.

  30. Ortrud

    Wow! The jewelry from these folks is always so BEAUTIFUL and skillfully crafted! I absolutely love these mystery boxes: what fabulous gifts they make! Thank you thank you !!!!

  31. Steve and Kathie

    Nice items and quick shipping

  32. Laurie

    Overall pleased- glad I got all studs, and I got a pair of sapphires I had my eye on (they’re my birthstone), and no repeats of anything I’d ordered before. I wasn’t sure about the Herkimer diamond/quartz studs, but they’re growing on me. The crescent shaped opals are too small for my liking, but since I got the mystery box, can’t complain (they typically take requests into consideration, but not sure about “mystery boxes”). As usual, fast shipping and unique costume pieces :)

  33. L
  34. Kitty

    Really lovely surprises! Prompt shipping!

  35. Kirsunen
  36. Emily
  37. Meghan

    Lovely mix of earrings I might not have picked for myself which is why I love mystery boxes!

  38. Ortrud

    These mystery boxes make the most perfect gifts!!! I hoped for a green stone selection since that is my daughter‘s favorite color, and oh my! These folks certainly didn’t disappoint!

  39. Ortrud

    This company never disappoints! I have purchased a number of the mystery boxes as gifts and they have all been works of art. This batch is perhaps the most beautiful yet! I had requested green stones if possible and look what I got— WOOHOO! So amazing!!! Thank you!

  40. shel
  41. Topher

    Beautiful selection of products, definite high quality for the price!

  42. Madeline

    I have bought many items from ringcrush and I am never disappointed! Love the thrill of the mystery box

  43. Jessica

    Très belles boucles, mais livraison un peu longue vu le prix.

  44. 1o20vw7r9a6qzr7o

    The mystery boxes are so fun. This is my second and I love both!

  45. ava

    Beautiful!!! I received all the stones I requested and they are perfect! Good quality, they wear well. Will purchase from this shop again. :)

  46. 1o20vw7r9a6qzr7o

    I love everything that I have received from Ring Crush! These mystery boxes are so fun.

One-of-a-Kind, Always

Handcrafted in Atlanta, Georgia

Sustainably Crafted

Gems upcycled from mining waste.

Shop with Confidence

100-day returns on unworn pieces.

Free US Shipping

In stock ships in 5–7 days; made to order 2–3 weeks.

R I N G ◦ S I Z E

R I N G ◦ S I Z E

Need help with your ring size? Contact us via email support@ringcrush.com, we have some clever tricks for remote sizing!

If your ring size is a half size or in between we recommend rounding up, as our ring shanks are very dainty and comfortably accommodate down to a half size difference. Unworn pieces can be returned within 100 days of delivery; return shipping is the buyer's responsibility unless the error is ours.

A R T I S A N ◦ T E C H N I Q U E

A R T I S A N ◦ T E C H N I Q U E

• We handcraft all of our one-of-a-kind wearable art pieces using a unique process we refer to as "Creative Chemistry"

• Our stones are sourced from countries all over the world - Ametrine from Bolivia, Opal from Australia, Peridot and Turquoise from the USA.

• Each stone is carefully selected and hand assembled with fine gold-filled metals, and a special paint is applied which allows electricity to run through the piece.

• Through careful calculation, and a complex series of very nerdy hand-applied chemical processes, an organically shaped smooth golden (or silver) bezel is formed around the gemstone.

S P E C I A L ◦  R E Q U E S T S

S P E C I A L ◦ R E Q U E S T S

We will do our best to accommodate your special requests made at checkout depending on availability. This includes special requests on gemstone size, color, shapes, and textures. Please remember that each gemstone is unique like you and will vary from the pictures above! If your special request is not available, we will send a product that falls within the item description.

Raw Gemstone Stacking Rings by Ringcrush

O U R ◦ E C O ◦ P R O M I S E

In 2021 we made it our mission to focus on sustainability. Our metals are made using 100% recycled silver and gold, and we supply our gemstones entirely from the waste stream. of the mining industry.

Minimizing Waste • To reduce waste, we sometimes arrange more than one item in a gift box. If you need more than one gift box, please let us know in the notes at checkout, we can provide additional boxes free of charge.

1 0 0 %  H A N D M A D E

1 0 0 % H A N D M A D E

All Ringcrush products are artfully handmade by an eclectic team of female Savannah College of Art and Design and Georgia Tech students and alumni in Atlanta, Georgia. Thank you for supporting our craft.

M O R E ◦  I N F O R M A T I O N

M O R E ◦ I N F O R M A T I O N

Listing is for one item. To achieve a multi-gemstone statement look, mix-and-match your favorite Ringcrush rings.

Testimonials

I purchased this for my girlfriend as a promise ring. She likes more unique rings. The shipping was quick and I added a not asking to pick one of the best stones they believed because I wanted it to be very special. They absolutely delivered on that. She loved it so much, the packaging was beautiful and as was the ring. 1000/10 loved this. Will absolutely be purchasing from this shop again.

It really shows how much effort and love goes into creating each one, and I love that each piece has its own quirks and features so that no two pieces are alike. I also love the variety and quality of the gemstones and materials you use, but mostly that you’re still able to keep the prices within an affordable rangeI tell all my friends and family about your shop because I’ve never seen anything like your jewelry before:)

love Ringcrush bc it’s run by an amazing person, she’s so nice and sweet. It’s always a pleasure to buy from a nice person and feel like your order matters

I had been looking for something different for Mother’s Day. I knew I wanted raw stone necklace or rings something more unique. I spent months trying to find something. When I came across your amazon page of raw stone stackable rings. I immediately searched each stone I would need and saved them all to a list telling my husband it was all I wanted for Mother’s Day. I was overjoyed to get them. It’s been two years and they are still just as beautiful as the day I got them. Now, I have some health problems and my beloved engagement ring no longer fits. So I started asking my husband to replace it with the raw diamond you make. Also want some earringsyou have wonderful products.

This ring is absolutely stunning! I found Ringcrush on a whim & am so happy I didn’t think twice about placing my order. I placed my usually size 7 & it fits perfectly. Elizabeth was super responsive & very helpful when I asked for this specific design. This is already a very special piece to me & I can’t wait to pass it down one day to my niece. I already have my eye on a necklace! Great customer service, fast shipping & amazing quality - I can’t wait for my next gorgeous piece!

I bought a mystery box a few months ago, and you included an aquamarine ring; which is my late grandmother’s birthstone. Obviously there was no way you knew that, but it made me so happy, like it was a little sign from her that she’s watching over me.

I quit my job and went to Africa to work with sharks which was a LONG time dream of mine. I felt really trapped and under appreciated at this job. I felt like a new person over there and when I launched my website and sold my first underwater photograph, I bought myself an opal ring from your shop on Etsy to remind me of what’s important. It reminds me of the ocean and I’m proud to wear it everyday. It’s really helped seeing that token of “success” to me, especially this year. :)

When I gave birth to my son, I died (but came back obviously) my wedding rings didn’t fit for almost a year after, so I bought the amethyst ring (his birthstone) to wear in replacement. I bought it for protection and healing, but to also remind me that I can overcome anything.

I love the uniqueness and beauty of all ring crush pieces! Within the past year I began my career working in a health care setting, which has been difficult with COVID-19. Luckily, I have been treating myself (or been treated by family member, since they know how much I love ring crush) to approximately one ring crush piece a month! It brings me so much joy and I look forward to it so much. Thanks for being a bright spot in my life during a time when things are a little more difficult

I was pregnant an didn’t feel connected to my baby. So I got a ring with her predicted birthstone on it and it helped soooooo much! I felt so in touch with her and started being able to accept my changing body and identity

Beautiful. Thank you very much; I love my rings and recommend them to everyone looking for unique designs. Thank you.

Ring crush is very close to my heart because I wear the rings everyday. I got the birthstones of my parents and sibling. I live halfway across the world from them. The rings make me feel like they are closer to me. They give me a different kind of feeling that my loved ones are there. On difficult time I look at the rings and think of them and it makes me feel so much better